Feature-by-Feature Comparison
| Feature | Storage Scholars | CollegeBoxes |
|---|---|---|
| Phone Response Time | 30 seconds | Standard U-Haul queue |
| Oversized Item Surcharge | No extra charge | $25-$50 per item |
| After-Graduation Shipping | Available | Not offered |
| Campus-Specific Teams | Student teams on 200+ campuses | Generic U-Haul network |
| Minimum Storage Term | Flexible | 4-month minimum |
| Photo Tracking | Photos at every step | Not prominently offered |
| Boxing/Reboxing Fee | No extra charge | $20 per box |
| Parent Brand | Independent (dedicated to college storage) | U-Haul subsidiary (general moving company) |
| Published Pricing | Personalized quotes reflecting your actual items | Published rates that exclude surcharges and fees |
| Movers | Campus-embedded student teams with school-specific knowledge | Generic professional movers with no campus familiarity |
| Insurance Per Item | Included | $100 declared value per box |
| Door-to-Door Pickup | Yes | Yes |
| Climate-Controlled Storage | Yes | Yes (U-Haul facilities) |
The Full Breakdown
Why Students Choose Storage Scholars
30-Second Phone Response
CollegeBoxes routes through U-Haul's general support queue, which means longer wait times during peak season. Storage Scholars answers within 60 seconds.
No Hidden Surcharges
CollegeBoxes charges $25-$50 for heavy items and $20 per box for boxing/reboxing. Storage Scholars pricing has no surprise fees.
Campus-Specific Knowledge
Storage Scholars teams are embedded at 200+ campuses. CollegeBoxes operates through U-Haul's generic nationwide network.
Flexible Storage Terms
No 4-month minimum. Store for exactly as long as you need.
After-Graduation Shipping
Ship items to your next destination. CollegeBoxes does not offer this.
What to Know About CollegeBoxes
U-Haul Affiliation
CollegeBoxes operates under U-Haul's umbrella, which means your service is routed through a large corporate system rather than a dedicated college storage provider. Support goes through U-Haul's general queue, and the experience is shaped by corporate logistics, not campus-specific needs.
Published Pricing
CollegeBoxes lists prices on their website, but the headline numbers exclude surcharges for heavy items ($25-$50 each) and boxing/reboxing fees ($20/box). The actual cost is often significantly higher than what is initially shown.
Professional Movers
CollegeBoxes uses U-Haul's professional movers rather than campus-embedded teams. While they have moving experience, they lack familiarity with specific dorm layouts, campus rules, and move-out schedules that Storage Scholars teams know firsthand.
The Bottom Line
Here is what you should know about CollegeBoxes: it is a U-Haul subsidiary, not a dedicated college storage company. That means your support calls go through U-Haul's general queue, surcharges for heavy items ($25-$50) and boxing fees ($20/box) can add $50-$100+ to your bill, and you are locked into a 4-month minimum. BBB complaints show patterns of destroyed items and months of unresolved claims. Storage Scholars was built from the ground up for college students, with campus-embedded teams, no surcharges, flexible terms, and 30-second phone support. For a service that actually understands the college move-out experience, Storage Scholars is the better choice.
Ready to skip the stress?
See how Storage Scholars compares for your school and items.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is CollegeBoxes cheaper than Storage Scholars?
CollegeBoxes starts around $48-$76 per item for 4 months. However, surcharges for heavy items ($25-$50) and boxing fees ($20/box) can add $50-$150. Storage Scholars includes all sizes without surcharges.
Does CollegeBoxes use professional movers?
Yes, through U-Haul's network. Storage Scholars uses campus-embedded student teams. The key difference is that Storage Scholars teams know your specific campus, dorm layouts, and move-out logistics.
Which is better for large or heavy items?
Storage Scholars. CollegeBoxes charges $25-$50 per heavy item and $20 for boxing/reboxing. No surcharges with Storage Scholars.
Can I store for less than 4 months?
Not with CollegeBoxes (4-month minimum). Storage Scholars offers flexible terms.
What happens if items are damaged?
CollegeBoxes includes $100 per box but BBB complaints show claims going unresolved for months. Storage Scholars provides photo documentation for faster resolution.
Can I switch from CollegeBoxes to Storage Scholars?
Yes. Check CollegeBoxes cancellation policy first, then get a quote at storagescholars.com.